Last Wednesday Kotaku republished (with permission, of course) my review of Modern Warfare 3s single player campaignA review in which I described it as an "un-game with a core of nastiness"This caught the attention of Kill Screen's Brendan Keogh, who wrote a riposte to my piece on the Australian K, in which he called me, in the nicest possible way, an "un-player", and detailed why he believed my article was incorrect.

He perhaps slightly misunderstood, so here is my reply: